The Original Crab Shanty

Situated right in the heart of City Island, The Original Crab Shanty is a beloved seafood restaurant that has become a staple for both locals and visitors craving authentic, satisfying seafood fare in the Bronx. This charming spot, located at 361 City Island Ave, delivers an inviting atmosphere that balances casual comfort with the salty seaside charm of its island surroundings. Whether you choose to dine inside or soak up the lively street vibes from their outdoor seating, the experience is as warm and welcoming as the aromas wafting from their kitchen.

The menu at The Original Crab Shanty reads like a seafood lover’s dream. From the moment you sit down, you’ll notice their dedication to offering hearty, well-executed dishes that celebrate the ocean’s bounty. Their Banquet for Crab Lovers is a showstopper — imagine succulent crab legs paired with a tender lobster tail and fried shrimp, all served alongside your choice of soup or salad and a satisfying side. The choice of soups is impressive, with both the creamy, comforting New England Clam Chowder and the bright, tangy Manhattan Clam Chowder making appearances, providing a perfect prelude to the main event. For those who appreciate classic seafood platters, the Fried Fisherman's Platter and Broiled Seafood Platter come generously packed with an irresistible variety of fresh catches.

One cannot talk about The Original Crab Shanty without mentioning their standout appetizers and sides. Raw oysters slice through with briny freshness, while the Chilled Seafood Combo Platter offers a refreshing medley of shrimps and crab, chilled to perfection. For a little indulgence on the sweeter side, their moist and decadent Chocolate Cake rounds out the meal with a perfect finishing touch.

Guests frequently highlight the value and portion sizes here, like D’Jillisser K who praises the $35.99 special as a satisfying feast that balances quality and quantity. Aaron Santiago speaks fondly of the restaurant’s quaint charm and notes how the pricing surprises with generous servings that are hard to beat on City Island. The friendly and knowledgeable service, like the top-notch hospitality of Cisco mentioned by Sports Opinion Log, only enhances the overall dining experience.

While some reviewers like Shelley P. suggest improvements in certain fried items and recommend sitting outdoors to better appreciate the ambiance, the overall consensus is that The Original Crab Shanty remains a reliable destination for anyone looking to enjoy fresh, flavorful seafood in a relaxed and authentic setting. Elena’s experience with their lunch menu highlights the diversity and richness of options — from shrimp pasta to ribs — catering well to varied tastes without compromising on quality or portion size.

Whether you’re a first-timer eager to try crab legs for the first time or a seafood connoisseur who knows exactly what you want, The Original Crab Shanty delivers both the robust flavors and the welcoming atmosphere that make a meal here memorable. The blend of New England-style seafood classics and well-loved comfort dishes invites you to savor each bite, making the crab shanty not just a meal, but a true celebration of coastal cuisine right in the Bronx.

For bookings or inquiries, you can reach them directly at +1 718-885-1810. If you find yourself on City Island craving a seafood feast that tugs at the heartstrings with its authenticity and generous portions, The Original Crab Shanty is undoubtedly a destination worth savoring.